[Met Performance] CID:128080
Manon {143} Metropolitan Opera House: 02/19/1940.

(Debut: Raoul Jobin
Review)


Metropolitan Opera House
February 19, 1940


MANON {143}

Manon...................Grace Moore
Des Grieux..............Raoul Jobin [Debut]
Lescaut.................John Brownlee
Count des Grieux........Nicola Moscona
Guillot.................Alessio De Paolis
Brétigny................George Cehanovsky
Poussette...............Annamary Dickey
Javotte.................Maxine Stellman
Rosette.................Lucielle Browning
Innkeeper...............Louis D'Angelo
Guard...................Max Altglass [Last performance]
Guard...................Arnold Gabor
Maid....................Gina Gola

Conductor...............Wilfred Pelletier


Review of Olin Downes in The New York Times

The performance of Massenet's "Manon" yesterday evening in the Metropolitan Opera House introduced to the audience the new Canadian tenor, Raoul Jobin, who made his New York debut as Des Grieux. Mr. Jobin obtained his Metropolitan appointment because of the impression he made at one of the Auditions of the Air. Tenors of any kind are too rare for a singer of Mr. Jobin's equipment to be readily discarded. He was in fact promoted to last night's stage without the formality of an elimination contest.

Mr. Jobin has sung at the Paris Opera as Tybalt. For two seasons he sang at Bordeaux Opera, later at the Paris Opera Comique, and last summer in the Municipal Theatre at Rio de Janeiro. His voice is warm in its best registers and when he does not force or exaggerate has a pleasing character. It becomes hard when he pushes it, especially at the top. His stage business is more effusive than distinguished, and his earlier scenes were more convincing than that, for instance, of the air "Ah, fuyez" in the seminary of St. Sulpice. His native feeling for the French text and his instinctive sympathy for the music, plus his serviceable routine, contrasted rather conspicuously with Miss Moore, whose Manon, sung in a capable way, has little of nuance, metier, or intensity.

In this performance John Brownlee substituted with competence for Richard Bonelli as Lescaut. Mr. Moscona enunciated an astonishing French as des Grieux pere, and shouted, and was far from characteristic of the role. Mr. Pelletier conducted, with vitality, if not invariable discretion. Little of the piquancy and charm of the opera was preserved in this performance. It attracted, however, the second big audience of the day, and there were cordial curtain calls for leading artists.



Added Index Entries for Subjects and Names


Back to short citation(s).