[Met Performance] CID:259700
La Gioconda {247} Metropolitan Opera House: 11/29/1979.

(Debuts: Bruna Baglioni, Jocelyne Taillon, James Courtney, Terry Emanuel
Reviews)


Metropolitan Opera House
November 29, 1979


LA GIOCONDA {247}
Ponchielli-Boito

La Gioconda.............Grace Bumbry
Enzo....................Carlo Bergonzi
Laura...................Bruna Baglioni [Debut]
Barnaba.................Mario Sereni
Alvise..................Paul Plishka
La Cieca................Jocelyne Taillon [Debut]
Zuāne...................Gene Boucher
Isčpo...................Andrea Velis
Monk....................James Courtney [Debut]
Steersman...............Herman Marcus
Singer..................William Mellow
Singer..................Paul De Paola
Dance...................Suzanne Laurence
Dance...................Jane Muir
Dance...................Marcus Bugler
Dance...................Terry Emanuel [Debut]
Dance...................Jack Hertzog

Conductor...............Giuseppe Patanč

Stage Director..........Bruce Donnell
Designer................Beni Montresor
Lighting designer.......Gil Wechsler
Choreographer...........Norbert Vesak

La Gioconda received ten performances this season.

Revival gift of Fredric LeVine

Review of Robert Jacobson in the March 1980 issue of Opera News


Returning to the world of grand opera, the Met revived Ponchielli's "La Gioconda" with, to steal from Pirandello, two Giocondas who are not Giocondas. (See December 28). The first night (Nov. 29) seemed too much like six characters in love with a prompter, so little did they relate to one another or manage to push the emotional temperature much above freezing. As a soprano, Grace Bumbry has a big voice, but one without voluminous sound. Unsupported in the upper middle, empty at midrange and yelled on top (where the tone seemed skimmed off rather than real), she had a tendency to wobble at all dynamic levels. Her pushed vocalizing, combined with unsympathetic acting of this hapless creature, left a large hole in the middle of the proceedings.

As Laura, debutante Bruna Baglioni revealed a smallish, brightly focused mezzo with little impact for the Act II aria and duets, while another debutante, Jocelyn Taillon, sounded shaky and mushy as La Cieca. Mario Sereni lent a choked, colorless baritone to Barnaha, acting not at all, and Paul Plishka made a sonorous, uneventful Alvise. So it was left to veteran Carlo Bergonzi, despite some shortness on top, to lend the right Italianate flavor to things with his brand of style and action. Giuseppe Patané, whose "Gioconda" proved so splendid at his debut a few seasons ago, appeared affected by his cast and so less involved, though he knows how to pace while mixing passion with detail. Bruce Donnell's direction did not always sort out the opera's chaotic happenings with alacrity, and Norbert Vesak's choreography for the "Dance of the Hours," busy and meaningless, tried to attempt an uneasy mixing of seria and buffa figures.


Review of Patrick J. Smith in Opera (UK)

The United States seems the only place left where the rumbustious fustian of Ponchielli's "La Gioconda" is ever put on view. Given first class singing, the opera still generates an excitement, probably because of its melodramatic libretto by the master Bono, although the music is stretched very thin over the Meyerbeer length of the evening.

The performance at the Metropolitan Opera (November 29) was presented in the "grand-opera" manner, by which I mean emphasis on full-throated emotion at the expense of any subtlety. Giuseppe Patané's conducting was smartly purposeful. Grace Bumbry's soprano, in the title-role, was heard loud and clear, after a somewhat veiled start. If her acting, and that of her colleagues, recalled the glorious days of opera as semaphore waggles and fists smote to brows, it seemed appropriate for this work. Carlo Bergonzi (no surprise) brought the most sense of style to the proceedings as Enzo, although the voice must now be carefully handled, and although he delivered "Cielo e mar" and much of the rest of the role as if singing a recital. Jocelyne Taillon made an acceptable Cieca; Bruna Baglioni a strong, if dry-voiced. Laura. Paul Plishka was his usual sonorous self as Alvise. Mario Sereni, as Barnaba, was miscast - his voice is a lyric baritone forced into a dramatic mode, and his stage presence is negligible.



Added Index Entries for Subjects and Names


Back to short citation(s).